Lesson 18
Agreeing, Disagreeing and Making Suggestions
4 min read
Why this matters
Technical discussions are full of opinions: which library to use, how to design an API, when to release. You need to agree in a way that adds something, disagree without starting a fight, and suggest ideas so people actually consider them. The right phrases make this much easier.
The core skill
Agreeing, with different strength
Choose how strongly you agree:
- Strong: Absolutely. / I completely agree. / Exactly.
- Normal: I agree. / That makes sense. / Good point.
- Partial: I agree up to a point. / That's true, but…
Agreement is more useful when you add a reason:
I completely agree. We've had three outages from that service this month,
so moving it is worth the effort.
Disagreeing politely
In English, direct disagreement (No, that's wrong) can sound rude. The usual pattern is: show you understand, then give your view and your reason.
I see what you mean, but I'm not sure GraphQL is the right choice here.
Most of our clients only need two or three endpoints, so it might add
complexity we don't need.
You learned softening words like might and I'm not sure in lesson 7. They are especially useful here.
Disagree with the idea, not the person. I'm not sure that will work is about the idea. You're wrong is about the person.
Making suggestions
Suggestions are often questions. They invite discussion instead of forcing an opinion.
What if we used feature flags instead of a separate branch?
How about splitting the migration into two steps?
Why don't we try it on staging first?
Maybe we could ask the data team for help.
Notice the verb forms:
- What if we + past simple: What if we used…? (The past makes it sound like an idea, not a demand.)
- How about + -ing: How about splitting…?
- Why don't we + base verb: Why don't we try…?
Reaching a decision
When a discussion goes in circles, help move it forward.
It sounds like we agree on the API design, but not on the timeline.
Can we decide the timeline on Thursday, when we have the estimates?
Useful phrases
Agreeing
- I'm with Priya on this.
- That's exactly what I was thinking.
- Good point. And also, it would make testing easier.
Partially agreeing
- That's true, but we also need to think about cost.
- I agree in principle, but the timing is difficult.
Disagreeing
- I see what you mean, but …
- I'm not convinced that this will be faster.
- I have a slightly different view.
- I'm not sure about that. My concern is …
Suggesting
- What if we added a cache?
- How about using the existing service?
- Have we considered a simpler approach?
- One option would be to ship it behind a flag.
Common mistakes
"I am agree with you." Agree is a verb, so you don't need am: "I agree with you."
"How about to use Docker?" After how about, use the -ing form: "How about using Docker?"
"I don't agree with you, it's a bad idea." Correct grammar, but too direct, and bad idea sounds personal. Explain: "I'm not sure about that, because it would double our hosting costs."
"Why we don't use a queue?" In this question, don't comes before we: "Why don't we use a queue?"
Formal vs. casual
- Architecture review with senior engineers: "I see the advantages of a microservice here, but I have some concerns about the operational cost. Have we considered keeping it as a module in the monolith for now?"
- Team discussion: "Hmm, not sure we need a whole new service. What if we just made it a module for now?"
Exercise
Think of a recent technical decision on your team, for example a tool, a design or a deadline. Write a short reply for a discussion where you:
- Partly agree with one idea.
- Disagree politely with another, with a reason.
- Make one suggestion, using What if we…, How about… or Why don't we…
Hint: say your reply out loud. Does it sound like you're attacking the idea or the person?
Recap
- Choose the strength of your agreement, and add a reason.
- Disagree by showing you understand, then giving your view and reason.
- Suggest with What if we…, How about + -ing, Why don't we…
- Agree is a verb: I agree, not I am agree.
- Help the group move to a decision.